Thinking about how to switch STR managers but worried about losing your reviews and future bookings? You’re not alone. It’s the number one reason owners stay with a manager they’re unhappy with. The good news is that with the right plan, you can protect most of what you’ve built on Airbnb and rebuild everything else faster than you’d think. Here’s how we help Savannah owners switch smoothly, step by step.

Why Owners Switch STR Managers
- Revenue has flattened while similar homes nearby are doing better
- Reviews are slipping because of cleaning or communication problems
- Owner statements are hard to understand, or fees keep appearing
- Slow replies to the owner, not just to guests
- No clear pricing strategy for Savannah’s busy and slow seasons
If a few of these sound familiar, our guide to choosing a Savannah vacation rental manager covers the questions to ask before you choose your next one.
The Best Way to Keep Your Reviews: Make Your New Manager a Co-Host
On Airbnb, reviews stay with the listing they were left on, and listings can’t simply be moved from one account to another, as 10xBNB’s guide to transferring Airbnb listings explains. The best way to switch STR managers and keep your reviews is to keep the listing where it is and add your new manager as a co-host. Your new manager takes over pricing, guest messages, and the calendar, and your listing keeps its reviews and its place in search.
This works when the listing is in your Airbnb account. If your old manager built the listing in their own account, the reviews generally stay with them.
One more thing to know: the co-host option is an Airbnb feature. On VRBO, Booking.com, and other sites, your new manager will usually create fresh listings, and those start with zero reviews.
Rebuilding Reviews Fast After You Switch STR Managers
Starting over sounds scary, but new listings can build momentum quickly. Airbnb gives new listings a boost in search to help them get their first bookings, and a smart launch makes the most of that window.
- Launch with sharp pricing. Price a little below similar homes for the first few weeks to win early bookings, then raise rates as reviews come in.
- Keep your calendar wide open. Turn on Instant Book, allow shorter stays at first, and fill gaps in your calendar.
- Make the first stays perfect. Extra attention on cleaning, fast replies, and a thoughtful welcome turn early guests into five-star reviews.
- Ask for the review. A friendly thank-you message after checkout reminds guests to leave a review while the stay is fresh.
- Answer every review. Thoughtful responses show future guests that someone is paying attention.
- Invite past guests back. Guests who loved your home before are the fastest path to new reviews and repeat bookings.
- Use great photos. Professional photos help a new listing stand out while it’s building its review count.
A manager with a strong track record helps too. Guests see the host’s overall reputation, not just the new listing.
How to Switch STR Managers Step by Step
1. Read your current management agreement
Look for the notice period, any termination fee, and what happens to reservations already on the books. Many agreements say the old manager keeps a fee on stays they booked, even after you leave.
2. Choose your new manager before you give notice
Line up your new manager first so there’s no gap in guest support, cleaning, or pricing. A good manager will build the transition plan with you.
3. Find out who owns each listing
Check whether your Airbnb listing is in your account or your manager’s. That decides whether you can keep your reviews by adding a co-host, or whether you’ll launch fresh.
4. Make a list of what you need back
- Your listing logins, or confirmation that you’re the listing owner
- Professional photos, if you paid for them
- Door codes, Wi-Fi details, smart lock and thermostat access
- Vendor contacts, appliance warranties, and maintenance history
- An inventory of furniture, linens, and supplies
5. Plan for future reservations
Existing bookings usually stay where they were made. The cleanest approach is to honor them and agree in writing who handles each guest, who gets paid, and when. Guests should never feel the change.
6. Update the city and tax accounts
Update the contact information on your Savannah short-term rental certificate and make sure lodging taxes are handled without a gap. Our Savannah STR permit guide covers the city’s requirements.
7. Time it for a slower season
If you can, switch STR managers in a quieter month instead of right before St. Patrick’s Day or a big wedding weekend. It gives the new team time to learn your home before the rush.
Mistakes to Avoid When You Switch STR Managers
- Giving notice before your new manager is ready
- Canceling guest reservations, which hurts your listing and your guests
- Letting the old manager delete a listing you own
- Forgetting to change door codes after the hand-off
- Skipping a written agreement on how future bookings are paid
Why Owners Switch STR Managers to Sid Was Here
Sid Was Here is a Savannah property management company that has been investing and managing locally for more than 20 years, with more than 2,200 guest reviews behind us. When you switch to us, we handle the transition: reviewing your agreement, joining your Airbnb listing as co-host when possible, launching new listings on other sites, planning around existing reservations, and getting your home on our pricing and cleaning systems.
Our fee is 20% of gross revenue, all-inclusive, with no setup fees or repair markups, and your first month is free. See how it compares in our guide to property management fees in Savannah, or read what it really costs to self-manage your Airbnb in Savannah.
Switching STR Managers FAQ
Will I lose my Airbnb reviews if I switch STR managers?
Not if the listing is in your Airbnb account and you add your new manager as a co-host. If the listing is in your old manager’s account, the reviews usually stay with them.
Does the co-host option work on VRBO?
Co-hosting is an Airbnb feature. On VRBO and other booking sites, your new manager will usually create new listings.
How fast can a new listing get reviews?
Faster than most owners expect. Airbnb boosts new listings in search, and smart launch pricing plus great first stays can bring in reviews within the first few weeks.
What happens to bookings I already have?
They usually stay where they were made. Most owners honor them and agree in writing who manages each stay and how payment is split.
Ready to Switch STR Managers?
We’d love to help you move over smoothly. Request a free revenue projection, get a property management proposal, or call us at (912) 525-0042.


